‘Russian court forbids spreading islamic writings’

Translated from German by Michael Laudahn:

From THIS German language news site

[Caption] A russian court put islamic writings on the extremism index



A court in the south russian city of Orenburg  has established a list of prohibited litterature comprising 65 islamic books, whose sale henceforth is illegal on russian territory. The verdict caused great outrage with the russian moslem community. The court classified the islamic publications as ‘extremist’. In Orenburg, there is a minority of moslem faith, until 1925 the entire district was part of the kazakh soviet republic. Today, Orenburg is situated near the Kazakhstan border, where more than 70 percent of the population are moslems.


Among the islamic litterature classified as dangerous are the well-known al-Bukhari and al-Muslim hadith collections, like also the books on the life of the prophet Mohammed (sirah) and the 40 hadiths of the imam An-Nawawi. A typical and verdict-causing text sample from the Sahih hadith goes like this:

[…] When the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) appointed anyone as leader of an army or detachment he would especially exhort him to fear Allah and to be good to the Muslims who were with him. He would say: Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war, do not embezzle the spoils; do not break your pledge […] If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah’s help and fight them. […] (Sahih Muslim 19:4294) [excerpt copied from http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Qur%27an,_Hadith_and_Scholars:Jizyah

The forbiddance caused sheer horror with the moslem community in Russia. The Mufti Council of Russia, the Central Office of the Islamic Congregation, the Moslem Coordination Centre for the Caucasus and more islamic institutions condemned the court’s decision sharply. The associations intend to appeal against the Orenburg court decision. Should the court’s decision be upheld, this could lead to a disgruntlement within the moslem community and beyond that to riots. Russia’s human-rights ombudsman, Vladimir Lukin, declared: ‘The fight against terrorism is a fight against the real planning of terror acts and the establishing of groups, not against the interpretation of old and holy books, no matter what persuasion.’ As the writings prohibited are part of classic islam, a forbiddance would be equivalent of a closure of all moslem libraries.


This decision is not the first one taking on religious litterature. Earlier, 68 Jehova’s Witnesses publications and 15 oeuvres of the late islamic theologian Said Nursi were classified dangerous and put on the federal list of extremist material, which means it is illegal to spread them or store them for spreading. Since november 2011, blocking the Jehova’s Witnesses’ website has been intensified. In december 2011, Russia’s ambassador to India apologised for the attempt to prohibit the book ‘Bhagavad Gita as it is’ in Russia for being extremist. It is of paramount significance for Hare-Krishna movement partisans. ‘It is not normal to send religious books to ignorants to have them checked’, added the ambassador, thereby expressing sharp criticism at the Tomsk (Siberia) University’s expert witnesses, who had classified the book as extremist.

About Eeyore

Canadian artist and counter-jihad and freedom of speech activist as well as devout Schrödinger's catholic

15 Replies to “‘Russian court forbids spreading islamic writings’”

  1. The reality is, as experienced by tens of millions of Westerners, is that there is no “Islam Lite”….no “Sharia Lite”……..there is just islam and muslims in all their excess and with all their demands, demands which never stop but grow exponentially in conjunction with their numbers…..

    As such, we now know that the only solution to our problems is the removal of every last vestige of islam from our countries and the criminalization of any form of islamic law.

    Once that has been done, coupled with changes to our immigration system, we will finally know peace…….until then….it will be absolute misery at the leisure of muslims..

    Regards, Don Laird
    Edson, Alberta, Canada

  2. There’s a whole lot of perverted junk in the Hindi texts like the Muhabharata (sp) and Baghavad Gita. It’s interesting to learn that Russia has an interest in protecting the secular nature of their culture. I hadn’t heard this before. So if you want to learn about the goddess Kali or whatever you can go to Amazon and get it? I guess they just ban the books in the stores.

  3. Not just Russia. Spain has just accepted a petition from a spanish ex muslim from Pakistan (so he knows what he’s talking about) to ban the Koran. It’s the first step in the legislative process and may not pass to the next level but it’s huge news that it was taken seriously and not ignored.

    Spain had to deal with the ETA for decades so are not coddlers of terrorism like England is. Furthermore they recall the 04 bombings. Lastly it is now known that islamists have Spain in their sights for a re-reconquista. Since the reconquista is still a big deal for the spanish I doubt they will be too sympathetic to those who want a reversal.

    So now the Koran now has a direct effect upon Spain’s national security.

    Add to that the almost daily news stories about all the islamic nonsense surrounding the London 2012 Olympics right now and, well, let’s just see how the Spanish legislature deals with this.

    I’m not sure about actual book banning but it really should be recognized as hate literature along the lines of Mein Kamph and The Turner Diaries because that is exactly how the literature us being used now.

    I read The Turner Diaries and it was very educational about how the Oklahoma city bomber and his accomplices thought.

    And also it was forbidden for muslims traveling in foreign countries to carry the koran with them. This is becaue they didn’t want non muslims to know how they thought AND didn’t want non muslims to be able to study the book to find material that would help it be disproved in debate.

    I’m sure they also didn’t want anyone to find out about abrogation – I hold that that was the reason Salman Rushdie was targeted for death – he brought the concept of abrogation to the attention of the non muslim public – and it’s a capital crime (even worse than screwing your donkey) to give away their “secrets”. It couldn’t really have been about depicting Muhamad as drunk or naked as those stories are in the foundational texts. Which seems worse – retelling widely known and “true” story about mohammad or telling the infidels that the “religion of peace” stuff is not even accepted as true by muslims – and is in fact a blatant intentional lie.

  4. Further…..

    The developments in Russia are really the tip of the iceberg around the world.

    As pointed out by Truthiocity there are waves of resentment growing around the world…

    Evidence of that can be found by looking very closely for the subtle hints as to changes in public sentiment…..

    Here’s an example….look at Congressman Keith Ellison….a very close friend of the Muslim Brotherhood and the terrorist front group CAIR…..Ellison can feel the winds of change and has been making very public statements as of late in order to distance himself from the Muslim Brotherhood.

    I think this trend will continue as the wave of anger towards islam and muslims continues to grow. Regardless of how much these supporters of islam and terror front groups like the Muslim Brotherhood retract their support and try to distance themselves…..we must always remember their duplicity and treasonous avocation of terrorism……to that end , both in Canada and the United States, they must be held to account and that accounting must be far reaching, have no expiration date and speak of an unmistakable sense of permanence and finality.

    Here in Canada one needs look no further than the lawyers who work vigorously to set free amongst us the convicted murderer and terrorist, Omar Khadr.

    Add to that list the Leftist academia and certain members of the judiciary…….not one single one of them must be allowed to fade away……their treasonous attempts to destroy two of the greatest nations in the history of Mankind, Canada and the United States of America, can never be forgotten……….ever.

    Regards, Don Laird
    Edson, Alberta, Canada

  5. Winston Churchill on Islam.
    “How dreadful are the curses which Mohammedanism lays on its votaries! Besides the fanatical frenzy, which is as dangerous in a man as hydrophobia in a dog, there is this fearful fatalistic apathy.
    “The effects are apparent in many countries. Improvident habits, slovenly systems of agriculture, sluggish methods of commerce, and insecurity of property exist wherever the followers of the Prophet rule or live.
    “Individual Moslems may show splendid qualities – but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world.

  6. Quote: As the writings prohibited are part of classic islam, a forbiddance would be equivalent of a closure of all moslem libraries.

    Eh? How so? Surely not all? I was under the impression that Islam is the RoP.

  7. Don you are right, the wave of resentment is growing around the world, this is what I have been expecting, it will grow into active resistance against the Islamic Conquest. This wave of resentment is why I keep saying that we can’t write off any nation or region and why we must keep fighting.

  8. Good point Richard…..and I agree.

    Islam and muslims, like a cancer, must be removed and their ability to effect change or any sort of regulation, legislation, law or policy neutralized. To do anything less is suicide.

    Those that remain must live under the threat of immediate deportation and or incarceration for the slightest infraction of laws relating to islam.

    Then we are faced with the prospect of removing and neutralizing firmly entrenched muslims and islamic infrastructure in areas like Dearborn, Michiagan and Scarborough, Ontario……this will require open confrontation and quite possibly, bloodshed.

    Our governments can begin by seeking out prominent members of the islamic community like The Toronto 18, Ali Hindi, Mohamed Elmasry and Omar Khadr who incite murder and hate and seek to destabilize Canada and standing them on trial for high treason and sedition.

    Convictions for these charges would result in long periods of time spent in far northern facilities, where upon completion of their sentence their assests would be stripped and they would be deported to the islamic country of their choice.

    Lawyers and academics like Dennis Edney, Nathan Whitling, Brydie Bethell, John Norris and Dr.Trish Fulton, who are handmaidens to islamic terrorists and the Muslim Brotherhood must be pursued vigorously and suffer crippling sanctions for their treasonous collaborations and support.

    We can no longer take a road of ignorance of those who, whilst wrapped in the robes of self righteous “defenders of democracy” and under the guise of human rights, recourse to the law and academic freedom, assist those who seek to draw a smothering cloak of oppression, persecution, darkness, depravity, murder and horrific barbarity across a magnificent nation and culture…..that of Canada.

    I, for one, will not allow it.

    The time is long overdue to start a process of identification of those who walk amongst us who seek our demise…..those lists must speak of unswerving particularity and as the winds of change continue to blow against the muhammadans, be used as instruments of accountability for their actions.

    Throughout the years of Nazi occupation of France there were patriots how quietly marked those men and women who assisted the Nazi’s…..those traitors were held to account with unmistakable force once the Bosch had be routed……so too now, must those who assist the Muslim Brotherhood and terrorist front groups like CAIR, ICNA, MAS and so many many others be held to account for their duplicity and treason.

    In closing, when I think of lawyers and judges who assist the muhammadans, when I think of the likes of Libby Davies, Justin Trudeau, Olivia Chow, Keith Ellison and so many many others I am reminded of the words of Marcus Tullius Cicero, a Roman statesman, lawyer and scholar, when he spoke of the traitors who move amongst us….he said……

    ““A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and carries his banner openly. But the traitor moves amongst those within the gate freely, his sly whispers rustling through all the alleys, heard in the very halls of government itself. For the traitor appears not a traitor; he speaks in accents familiar to his victims, and he wears their face and their arguments, he appeals to the baseness that lies deep in the hearts of all men. He rots the soul of a nation, he works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the pillars of the city, he infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist. A murderer is less to fear. The traitor is the plague.”

    The Trudeaus, Fulton’s, Edney’s and Khadr’s must never be forgotten…..ever.

    Regards, Don Laird
    Edson, Alberta, Canada

  9. Don you are right, unfortunately some of our liberty is going to be permanently removed during this war, I don’t know how or when this war is going to become a major conflict or when it will be over. I do know that we are going to have to return to the past when all nations enforced their cultural values and protected them like mothers protecting their children.

  10. The problem here is that apart from authorities on Islam very few people ever read Al Bukhari or Al Muslim. So my feeling is that the Spanish approach of banning the Koran started by a brave counter Jihadist from Pakistan is the best approach. Hit them where it hurts: The Koran. Also their are those good pastors in America who burn the Koran. That is what they really care about.

  11. You, all, say what you do not know.
    Islam is not what you say.
    READ IT before writing theses nonsense. Winston Churchill was a Freemason (False Jew).
    Read the Generous Qura’an or Prophet Muhammad’s adages then comment, not follow the media.

  12. @ Marwanyafi:


    Also reliance of the traveler, hadiths and Suna and don’t forget to read koran in chronological order as later verses abrogate earlier ones. For that matter just read the last couple of chapters that way and you will understand tardism, AKA Islam. The most savage of the savage. The religion of hate and lies. As witnessed by the comment about Churchill. Find me a border between Islam and a neighbor that is not a bloody one. Then lets talk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.